
Written by Victoria Ongko
Artwork by Victoria Ongko for The Fraser Post
Edited by Kalpita Gangwar
AI-generated Art: What Defines an Artist?
How AI has blurred our perception of art, addressing frustrations, and how to see the silver lining as an artist.
OPINION
To preface, this article is heavily opinionated and mostly based on my own thoughts, as well as the insights of professional artists, actors and writers. I write this as an aspiring professional artist myself.
I fell in love with art and drawing around four to five years ago. Ever since, I’ve been obsessed with capturing a world that only exists inside my mind, longing to bring life to the imaginary and incorporeal. Though, ironically, creativity is where my biggest weakness lies. I fear that I’ll be unable to think of anything individual, and I’ll become nothing more than a nameless, unrecognized artist who only pursued art because they didn’t want to do anything else, not because they would bring new life to the industry.
This is why, when I look at how quickly AI-generated art has progressed over the past year, my stomach churns with anxiety. This could potentially threaten my dream career; how will this affect me as someone who wants to rely on art financially? How good will AI art get? And as someone who struggles with creativity, who thought that sharpening my skill would balance out that flaw, will I eventually become expendable?
Art has always been looked down upon to some degree, even before the rise of artificial intelligence. It has been undervalued, deemed unnecessary, and creatives have often been ridiculed for sacrificing a “real job” – a job that “actually makes money” – for a job that requires passion, as creative jobs are generally seen as inferior to higher paying jobs. In our capitalistic society, many believe that a career that is driven by passion but is less financially rewarding is a childish, unrealistic pursuit. This perspective has only intensified since the rise of AI art. Why hire artists for projects when you can just generate the image you need? Why waste time practicing art when there’s a machine that can do it better and faster? Why do we even need artists at all? This sentiment stems from ignorance towards the inherent purpose of art itself.
Art is, by definition, “the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination.” As an essential defining factor of humanity, it’s a way for artists to process their lives and hold up a mirror to our society. It vitalizes the world around us through human expression and beauty. Art is also one of the reasons that we’re able to catch a glimpse of history, and temporarily share the experience of those who lived centuries ago. Successfully replacing human artists with a non-human system is impossible; without human application, art does not exist. AI art has blurred this definition, reducing art to nothing but a pretty picture. As Studio Ghibli director Hayao Miyazaki bluntly puts it, after being shown AI generated work in 2016, “I strongly feel that this is an insult to life itself.” To define it more concisely, art is rooted in the human process, the human component, and the human experience – all this is lost once it’s just generated. It’s a similar reason to why we consider Van Gogh’s The Starry Night to be more artistic than a toddler’s snot smeared onto paper.
Aside from costing artists their jobs, a common concern about AI art is directed towards how it functions. The way AI art works, in a rudimentary simplification, is through a large dataset of images and text descriptions. This means that many artists whose work is publicly shared are subject to having their art inputted into this dataset – without their knowledge or consent. I looked through the list of thousands of artists whose work was stolen to train Midjourney, and it’s almost depressing. It’s a slap in the face to those who spent years honing their style and skill, who spent countless sleepless nights trying to perfect their work so they could finally be satisfied with its quality – only for it to be replicated so easily. This is why many people believe that it’s ridiculous to refer to AI art as “real art”. It can be seen as something that is not art, but rather a crude imitation of the hard work of hundreds of thousands of artists. For those whose art has been unwillingly used, it feels somewhat uncanny when the AI generates their specific style – some artists say that it’s infringing or disturbing that they can see their hand in the AI art (Chayka, 2023).
With the recent actor and writer strikes, it has begun to seem like artificial intelligence benefits no one but those in power. For context, the 2023 SAG-AFTRA strike has been the longest walkout in the US actors’ union’s history, totalling up to one hundred eighteen days. Among other prevalent issues, one of the main goals of the strike was to prevent artificial intelligence from replacing actors on set. They eventually settled with AI reproductions of actors only being permitted with informed consent and compensation of the actors (Dalton, 2023). Still, the notion that it was seen as ethical to begin to replace actors with AI in the first place is extremely appalling and greedy. I can almost hear the sighs of content: “Oh, great! Soon, I’ll barely have to pay writers, actors, or artists because I can just generate everything! I can pump out five movies a month and make billions of dollars a year!” Why anyone would think this – a world where artistic expression is reduced to something so algorithmic and formulated – is an acceptable future for creative work is beyond me. This article I read soundly shares my opinion: “Our society is already becoming isolated and antiseptic, we look at screens all day long, colour is being stripped out of our shared spaces and there’s a sameness to modern society. Everything is starting to feel as if it’s controlled by an algorithm. Taking away the human component to the last holdout of society—art—seems truly nefarious to me” (Hudson, 2023). Replacing artists with artificial intelligence, especially those who work in entertainment, feels dystopian if not unethical.
Despite my rambling about how I hate the way AI art is being used, and my considerably sentimental take on art, I don’t dislike AI art itself. I think that it can be a good way for artists to enhance their creativity. Take Pinterest, for example, a website that artists often use for drawing references or uncovering ideas. I believe that AI art can benefit artists if it’s used similarly – a way to spark creativity and help visualize their own imagination. It could possibly act as a convenient way to generate a reference, rather than wasting time searching for the perfect reference photo, as artists often do. Admittedly, I haven’t used this method myself. The emergence of AI art will take some getting used to before it feels ethical to use it as a tool. However, this seems to be the case for most new technology in art-related fields – for example, when digital art was first introduced, many artists were uncomfortable with it because they thought that it shouldn’t be considered “real art” because of its functionality and shortcuts. One of my older art instructors spoke of how he spent hours upon hours practicing straight lines in school, but digital art apps enable anyone to draw a perfectly straight line in seconds, which instantly devalued all of his practice. But, over time, digital art proved to be just as equal of an art medium as traditional art. Of course, this is a different matter than AI art, as artists still need a substantial amount of practice and skill to create compelling work with digital art. Regardless, this serves as an example of how many people have an initial instinct to fear the unfamiliar, rather than decide how to work with it and use it to their advantage.
To conclude, the main issues with AI generated art are not that it’s “going to replace artists” or that “art will become insignificant,” because such things are impossible. AI cannot replicate the years of effort and dedication that artists have, nor can it completely remove the importance that art holds in our fundamental humanity. The issues with AI are the way it’s currently being used, how it’s being monetized, and its impact on how artists are perceived by society.
To my fellow artists – it may be time to consider what small jobs may vanish due to AI and how we can overcome some of the obstacles that are now in place. Although it can be argued that AI could be beneficial towards artists, it will do more harm than good until its value is changed. In navigating the complex intersection of artificial intelligence and art, it becomes imperative for us to advocate for the ethical use of AI, so that we can strive towards a future where technological innovation effectively complements rather than diminishes the intrinsic value of human creativity.
Works Cited
Chayka, Kyle. "Is AI Art Stealing from Artists?" The New Yorker, 10 Feb. 2023, https://www.newyorker.com/culture/infinite-scroll/is-ai-art-stealing-from-artists.
Dalton, Andrew. "SAG-AFTRA Strike: Hollywood Officially Over." Fortune, 6 Dec. 2023, https://fortune.com/2023/12/06/sag-aftra-strike-hollywood-officially-over/.
Hudson, Kate. "Artists Team Up in Class Action Lawsuit Against Major AI Generators." The Mary Sue, 19 Jan. 2023, https://www.themarysue.com/artists-team-up-in-class-action-lawsuit-against-major-ai-generators/.
_edited.jpg)