top of page

Some of y’all are not ready for this conversation, and it shows.

​

One of the main criticisms of Gilmore Girls, the most iconic and beloved show of the early 2000s, is that its leading heroine, Rory Gilmore, had the most disappointing character arc of all time. And I agree—watching the downfall of a fun, lighthearted, and relatable character sucks. However, I do believe her character development is quite realistic and raw while also being disappointing.

​

Before you venture any further into my tangent, be aware that this article contains spoilers for Gilmore Girls and its spinoff, Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life. So if you haven’t finished watching both shows, stop reading, watch them, and then come back (note: the spinoff is the worst piece of television to ever exist in history and should never have been made). 

​

You still here? Yay! Let’s get into it.

​

Allow me start with a caveat: Rory was never that great of a character to begin with. No one wants to hear it, but it’s the truth. She didn’t understand the sacrifices her mother made to ensure she had a good life, was never appreciative of anyone, and was an overall brat. Right from the first episode, she wanted to stay at Stars Hollow High for a boy she had just met, completely disregarding all of the hard work Lorelai (her mother) did to ensure she got a good education. 

​

As the show progressed, Rory just got worse. She dropped out of Yale and started freeloading off of her grandparents in their pool house. Did she ever consider that, as a twenty-something-year-old college dropout, she should get a job? Or offer to help around the house? Or do anything to advance her future? Nope, of course she didn’t. It’s disappointing that she was so entitled, but it’s not at all surprising. Really, we shouldn’t have expected anything from her. Because no one ever bothered to take her off her high horse.

​

Right off the bat, all Rory ever received was praise. Praise for her academics (which I’ll get into later), praise for her beauty, praise for her kindness and innocence. She was being applauded left and right, but was never criticized, and this lack of criticism is what ruined her. A person needs to receive constructive criticism to grow and understand how to be a better person. In Rory’s case, it would have saved her from a lot of mistakes in life because she would have known that the world didn’t revolve around her and her needs. But, no one ever told her she was wrong. Even when she was wrong, everyone defended her.

​

When Rory was hit by a deer and was late for her exam, rather than approaching the situation maturely, Lorelai just told everyone off. Rory, obviously, followed her mother and bought into the narrative that she was not responsible for what happened (even though Rory was the one who had slept in). Lorelai enabled Rory’s entitled behaviour, and as the adult, she should have taken responsibility for the situation (which she didn’t) or accepted that Rory was wrong (she didn’t do that either). 

​

After living this extremely sheltered life, Rory spiraled at every little mistake she made and never learned from them. This completely stunted her personal growth and gave her a complex, so at the first major life obstacle she faced, she decided to commit a crime and drop out of school, leading to her downfall.

But, does Rory’s character “downfall” really count as a downfall when she was a pretty bad character to begin with?

​

Now, I’ll give Rory a bit of leeway here. She was conditioned to believe that she was perfect, and when she wasn’t, she spiraled out of control. No one can really blame her for that. But, why couldn’t she pick herself up after being knocked down a peg. How come a minor piece of constructive criticism completely threw her life on track?

​

The short answer: Rory became a burned out gifted kid. It’s a tale as old at time: a child with incredible academic abilities becomes mentally exhausted later on in life due to the unrealistic expectations put on by themselves in others. And in Rory’s case, she was subjected to both.

​

I think the most disappointing part about Rory’s downfall is how relatable it is. She was the picture perfect student, until she wasn’t. We, as high achieving students, try so hard to get perfect grades, participate in clubs, boost our university applications, and when we fall short of this image we made in our minds, we break. It happens, and watching it happen to our favourite fictional character is somehow so much worse.

​

Rory’s aptitude and passion for learning, particularly journalism, carried her throughout all of high school, but when she got to university and was given a taste of real life, all the pent up burnout and exhaustion inside came out and she fell on her face.

​

The show did a great job as painting Mitchum Huntsberger—Rory’s boyfriend’s dad and her former boss—as the bad guy. How dare he tell Rory she was not cut out for journalism? How dare he stomp all over that young, twenty something year olds dream? 

​

In reality, Mitchum was never the bad guy. He just called it like he saw it. At the end of Rory’s internship at his newspaper, he told her that she didn’t have what it took to be a journalist—and he was right. Rory sat quietly in the corner, listened politely, fetched coffee, but she never jumped into the conversation. She never tried to find stories. She never acted like a journalist. Mitchum wasn’t even mean when he was giving her the feedback; if anything, he felt bad that he had to crush her dreams. Mitchum was the only person who was bluntly honest with Rory, and so he was painted to be the villain. 

​

We all know what happens from here: Rory steals a boat, drops out of Yale (why did you drop out of Yale?), moves in with her grandparents, joins the DAR, and then gets a wakeup call from her ex-boyfriend (who was her soulmate) and returns to school.

From there, it seems like Rory has finally learned her lesson and realized that the world doesn’t revolve around her. Her future seems bright and it looks like she beat that gifted kid burnout and will go on to be incredibly successful in life.

​

Flashforward 10 years into the revival, A Year In The Life, and her life was even worse than it was before. She doesn’t have a job, is jumping between cities, and as she told her soulmate ex-boyfriend—she doesn’t even know where her underwear is (and like a gentleman, he offers to buy her some). 

​

Rory doesn’t really go through any character development in AYITL, but we do get glimpses into the struggles of her life, her main issue being that she doesn’t have a job and is still “figuring things out.” Girl, you were still “figuring things out,” in your twenties—you’re 32 now, get your act together!

​

It appears as though Rory’s gifted kid burn out caught up to her once again—partially because she never learned how to deal with criticism and process failure—so she’s struggling again. By the end of the revival, she’s working on a novel (which her soulmate ex-boyfriend recommended she do, which is the second time he has gotten her life back on track), and it looks like she found her big passion project. But will it last? Unless they make another show, we’ll never know.

​

The point of this whole piece (or rant) is that Rory was never perfect and while disappointing, her downfall and character development was not surprising. Don’t dwell too much on this, though. Gilmore Girls is meant to be a fun, lighthearted show. If you try to psychoanalyze it, you’ll end up hating it. So take it for what it is and enjoy it (but also, don’t try to be like Rory, take care of your mental health, and know that criticism does not make you a failure).
 

​

​

Written by Nanki Bains

Artwork by Sidra Mohammed for The Fraser Post

Edited by Anjiya Tejani

Why Rory Gilmore’s Character Development was Incredibly Accurate

Who really takes a moment to stop and think about the world around them?

OPINION

​

bottom of page