top of page

During quarantine, Taylor Swift released her critically acclaimed albums “folklore” and “evermore.” Although Swift is known for her storytelling abilities, these albums brought a new angle that she had not previously explored - fictional tales. She created beloved characters, each with their own storylines. Here is my official ranking for all those characters! 

 

Disclaimer: I won’t be ranking any real people she has mentioned in her songs, such as Marjorie Finlay or Rebekah Harness. 

 

The characters I will be ranking, (in alphabetical order, not my actual ranking):

​

  • Augustine

  • Betty

  • Dorothea 

  • Este

  • Inez 

  • James

​

1. Inez

 

Inez is only mentioned in one song - “betty,” from Swift's album “folklore” (as are many of these characters). The line goes “you heard the rumors from Inez, you can’t believe a word she says most times, but this time it was true.” This references the famous “folklore” love triangle between Betty, James, and Inez. She essentially tells Betty that James is cheating on her. 

 

Although she is barely mentioned, I love Inez. She seems so entertaining to me! First of all, she was the first person to inform Betty about the rumors that were running amok in their school. Why did nobody else bother to tell her? Yes, she is described as being a gossip, but aren’t we all? Doesn’t everybody love an interesting piece of drama to spice up their day? To be honest, If Inez was real, I don't think I would talk to her much, just because of her tendency to lie. But again, her lying gives her a strong personality. Just with one line, it builds a strong foundation of who Inez is, and that's what's so satisfying about her character. I wish we had more of her.

​

2. Este 

 

TW: Mention of death and murder

​

Like Inez, Este did not have much song time. Unfortunately, that’s because she gets killed. Her friend sets out to earn justice for Este’s death. Her song is “no body, no crime” from the album “evermore,” a compelling murder mystery where Este is the first victim. 

 

The main reason I like Este so much is because I want to know more. I want to know more about her tumultuous marriage (that was connected to her unlucky end) and I want to know more about her friendship with the narrator. In the song, we only listen to her question her husband's loyalty, and then she's gone! The main character of this whole song disappeared so fast. Este deserved better than what she got. On top of that, the song creates a great and intricate story, with the plot immensely supporting the characters. Because of this, you are pulled into every aspect of the storyline, including Este. All in all, I just think she would be so incredible to learn more about.

​

3. Betty 

 

Betty is from the “folklore” love triangle, especially present in the songs “betty” and “cardigan.” “betty” is from the perspective of James, who cheats on her with what he calls a summer fling. We’ll touch on him later (spoiler alert: he's my least favorite). “cardigan” is a heart wrenching song from the perspective of Betty. She reminisces about her lost relationship and the scars his betrayal has left her with. 

 

Betty is a solid character! She doesn’t particularly stand out to me like Inez or Este do, but her expression in “cardigan” makes me feel as if I’ve been exactly what she's been through. That says a lot considering I’ve never been through serious heartbreak. Betty hasn’t really done anything wrong; she’s a girl who had her heart broken. It’s something many people can relate to. This makes Betty a warm, comforting and familiar character. She seems like an empathetic person who you feel like you can always count on. However, she's ranked in the middle because her character traits aren’t quite captivating. 

 

4. Augustine

 

Augustine is also from the love triangle, with her song being “august,” an August staple. She is the girl that James has a “summer fling” with, and she describes it as “summer love.” Augustine soon realizes that her and James had different views on their short-lived relationship. 

 

Even though Augustine is on the lower side of this list, I still like her. In “august,” she describes holding onto a false sense of hope that things may have a fairytale ending. Having this false sense of hope is something everybody practices, regardless of whether they know the truth or not. A lot of people can identify with Augustine’s experiences, including me. For this reason, I really resonate with her. However, I’m not sure I agree with the decisions she made, considering that she was aware of Betty and James' relationship. I believe she shouldn’t have pursued James,  that’s why I’ve decided to put her below Betty. But ultimately, James is responsible for his own choices and Augustine is still a great character with a great story. 

​

5. Dorothea

 

“dorothea” tells the story of reminiscing about an old friend that you’ve now parted with. The narrator expresses their lasting love for their friend, and reassures her that they will always be there for her. 

 

"dorothea" is a beautiful song. It conveys the feeling of that warm, long lasting care that you can have for a friend you’ve grown apart from perfectly. Throughout your life, you will meet many “Dorotheas.” The lyrics can connect well enough with anybody. The thing is, for me, I don’t connect to Dorothea as much as I connect with the narrator. Dorothea is shown to be famous and living in a big city. She used to be a friend the narrator met in high school. The line goes, “but are you still the same soul I met under the bleachers?” We don’t learn much about Dorothea’s own personal feelings, opinions or battles. This makes her one dimensional to the audience. While I don't have anything against this character, I just don’t have enough information to care, nor enough of a desire to learn more.
 

6. James

 

James, as mentioned earlier, is my least favorite character. This is quite self-explanatory. As you probably know by now, James betrays Betty’s trust. In response, he writes the song “betty” as an ATTEMPT at an apology. 

 

Interestingly enough, he doesn’t ever apologize throughout the song. He doesn’t even take accountability, he just dances around the subject. He goes on to blame Augustine and refers to her as “a figment of my worst intentions.” He even tells Betty that he saw her dancing with another boy as justification. Although you could argue that James calls his actions “the worst thing” he’s ever done, he still focuses on finding excuses rather than a sincere apology. James just has this sense of entitlement to him, like he can do anything just because he has outside factors to fall back on. It’s like when you procrastinate doing your homework, because who starts their homework at 7:42? You use that as an excuse, but deep down you know you’ve been putting it off. He uses every possible thing to try and justify his cheating. That's why he is dead last on this list. 

Written by Maaneha Malik

Artwork by Vareesha Shiraz for The Fraser Post

Edited by Hannah Khindria

ROARING REVIEWS

My Ranking of Taylor Swift's Characters

Her song is “no body, no crime” from the album “evermore”, a compelling murder mystery where Este is the first victim.

bottom of page