A Deep Dive Into Taylor’s Version Re-Recordings
In 2021, Taylor Swift made history by re-recording one of her most iconic albums, Fearless. As many are aware, she did this to gain complete ownership of her music since issues with her previous record label caused her to miss out on the royalties from her songs. Her new versions, just like the original ones, are definitely incredible, but as with every piece of media, these albums can be critically ranked. These rankings will be based almost entirely on the “From The Vault” songs that each album has given us, so consider this more as a ranking of the new (old) songs released with these re-recordings.

ROARING REVIEWS
Ranking all the Taylor’s Version re-recordings to commemorate the release of 1989 TV!
Written by Rhea Huria
Artwork by Anniyah Govani for The Fraser Post
Edited by Anya Bender
#4: Speak Now (Taylor's Version)

There are only four TV re-recordings out at the moment, with two hopefully on the way soon, so let us begin with the difficult position of fourth place: Speak Now TV. This is still an incredible album, certainly making it to the list of the best Taylor albums, but the Vault songs on Speak Now TV are unfortunately outshined by the other TV albums. Still, this re-recording gave us “I Can See You”, a song that has not left our heads since its release, the much-awaited Fall Out Boy collaboration on “Electric Touch,” and even a Hayley Williams collab on “Castles Crumbling,” all of which are special additions to the Taylor Swift discography. “When Emma Falls in Love,” “Foolish One,” and “Timeless” also deserve recognition for being flawless songs, fitting in nicely with the musical sound Speak Now contains. The nostalgia brought about by the re-release has been immense, although the loss of Swift’s country accent and the difference in the mood the songs give due to her singing with increased maturity and experience are certainly noticeable changes. That being said, this album is a masterpiece, and ranking it lowest in terms of TV re-recordings was not an easy decision at all. But something had to be last, so sadly, Speak Now TV had to take this place.
Third place goes to the newest addition to the TV collection: 1989. It is definitely an amazing album, and we have all had it on repeat since its recent release. Although it is only on the Deluxe version, “Bad Blood” with Kendrick Lamar gave us everything and more. “Now That We Don’t Talk,” “Suburban Legends,” and “‘Slut!’” bring some synth-pop to the album, while “Say Don’t Go” combines that genre with some soft-rock for a heart-wrenching but peaceful song. “Is It Over Now” has a completely different tone with electropop, but the uniqueness is refreshing. The album is very well-balanced, and we can just wait to see which songs are going to become the most iconic additions to Taylor Swift's discography. But for now, although this album has Taylor’s Version of some of her most popular songs, the new Vault additions are unfortunately outshined by her first few TV re-recordings.
#3: 1989 (Taylor's Version)
Next on the list is the re-recording that started it all: Fearless TV. Honestly, all of these rankings are very close, but Fearless’s Vault songs define its position. Fearless gave us the global hit “Mr. Perfectly Fine,” a song that many Swifties even consider their favourite. This song, believed to be about her past relationship with Joe Jonas, has a mid-tempo country-pop tune with pop-rock elements. Essentially, it’s very classic Taylor Swift, with a catchy chorus, a novel intro, and a dramatic bridge. Fearless TV also gave us collaborations with Keith Urban and Maren Morris, as well as the melancholic “We Were Happy,” quiet passion with “Don’t You”, and the upbeat piano-pop song “Bye Bye Baby.” Other than “Mr. Perfectly Fine,” Fearless has much more controlled vocals, and the instrumentals are softer than in most Taylor Swift albums, so it is definitely a slightly unique gem between Swift’s other albums. This is not to say it is a negative change; it is well-loved by Swifties around the world for a reason. Overall, Fearless TV is always going to be the go-to for some peace, and its timeless hits are what give it the silver medal in the Taylor’s Version rankings.
#2: Fearless (Taylor's Version)
Finally, first place goes to the emblematic second re-recording of 2021, Red TV. Red is number one because it just has hit after hit, and every Vault song stands out in its own way. Most obviously, Red gave us the 10-minute version of “All Too Well,” one of the most prominent songs of 2021 and music history in general. This ranking may be full of personal bias, but the sweeping fame of “All Too Well” cannot be disputed. The short film of “All Too Well” has also been viewed more than 92 million times as of right now, showing how absolutely iconic this song is. Red gave us some amazing collaborations too; Phoebe Bridgers, Chris Stapleton, and Ed Sheeran all make appearances on this album, which is no small feat. “Better Man,” “Babe,” “Forever Winter,” and “The Very First Night” also came from this album, making it clear that there is not one song on this album that is not a worldwide success. Red TV also gave us “Message In A Bottle”, which deserves a special mention as one of the best car songs, and songs in general, to ever exist. This album just has it all, and although all the TV re-recordings do too, Red TV truly stands out for its “From The Vault” songs.
#1: Red (Taylor's Version)
All of the TV albums, and all Taylor Swift albums in general, are truly difficult to rank due to their high level of quality and diversity of songs. Ranking them was almost impossible, but some albums stand out more than others. Red TV brought some of the most incredible Swift songs and lyrics out from the Vault, so it does get the crown of best TV re-recording - for now. Because the next Taylor’s Version re-recordings are definitely on their way, and there is no doubt that they will all be great competitors for first place in the TV rankings.
.png)


_edited.jpg)