top of page

Is teaching elementary students how to write in cursive a necessary skill, or a lesson from the past?

How many of us can write in cursive? Likely, most of us have some cursive handwriting skills; back when we were in elementary school, cursive was a standard lesson our teachers taught us. However, in these last few years, there has been much debate surrounding whether or not cursive is truly a required skill to succeed in the world of the future. Both sides of the story make sense, although one perspective may be more evident.

 

One of the biggest arguments in support of teaching cursive is the practice it gives children to improve their motor skills. Cursive handwriting is more effort-based for most, and the hand muscles used to write it are different from block writing as we all know and are comfortable with. But a lot of people see this as a negative. Many consider this additional effort to be a waste of time, especially in those early foundational years when children must be taught an abundance of important life skills. Should that time not be spent on learning other crucial subjects that may come up more prominently for the remainder of that child’s time in school? Besides that, motor skills can be taught to children in many alternate ways. When children play with toys such as building blocks, use cutlery to eat, and learn to tie their shoelaces, they are developing their motor skills. Writing in cursive is clearly not the only way to build these skills, so it does seem unnecessary from this point of view. 

​

People also often say that learning cursive connects children to history because older legal documents were, at times, written in cursive. Kids might not be able to read the old letters their great-grandparents sent each other, and they could miss out on the key moments of history solely due to their inability to read the handwriting. This argument can be easily debunked, however. First of all, most legal documents from historical periods that apply to us today are written in print font. In fact, the original 1867 version of the Canadian Constitution was printed at the press in a font that is certainly not cursive. As such, historical reasoning for learning cursive seems irrelevant because there are not many documents from before 1867 that would be read by children in history classes at schools. Secondly, even if students were to end up needing to read documents from before that time period, they are all now available and accessible online in PDF format. There are Renaissance-era documents available digitally now because technology has become increasingly more advanced. This extreme forwardness that is brought about by access to the internet removes the need to read and write in cursive, making it an old and obsolete skill. 

​

The last major argument made by those who support the teaching of cursive handwriting is founded on the basis of something we must all have: signatures. Many say that students must learn how to write cursive in order to create their own signatures. Signatures are absolutely required of us in the world today and throughout history - they are needed for everything, ranging from field trip permission forms to the purchasing of houses. The detail that is mostly overlooked in this argument though, is the fact that most people’s signatures are not necessarily written in cursive. Mostly, signatures come in many forms of swirly illegible strokes that usually cannot be differentiated from haphazard lines doodled on a page. Very rarely do people have signatures in true cursive. Your signature could, for example, just consist of one line, completely horizontal, and that would not be considered an issue. You can also often just print your signature; that is usually required anyway when signing documents. While cursive might be the historically common form used when signing forms and checks, the current times are drastically different. Nowadays, most forms of signatures are online, and digitally written signatures are becoming increasingly common. There just does not seem to be a need to spend hours perfecting the connected letter format of cursive, as technology now allows us to create those letters in already formatted cursive fonts. That time wasted away in classrooms may be spent practicing a skill that will never come up again in the lives of those students. 

​

Cursive is undeniably a visually appealing form of handwriting that had been the go-to for every piece of written work by writers and poets of the past. It could help bond children with the cursively written letters from history and create a signature they will use very often throughout their lives, all while giving them a chance to build some skills. It’s just not the most effective or efficient way to accomplish those goals. Instead of learning a font of writing that they will not need in their professional lives, children can read modernized versions of historical documents, make signatures composed of whichever lines they feel like drawing, and practice other activities that allow them to develop their motor skills. It is time to consider cursive a skill of the past and embrace some of these changes that the world is bringing.

Written by Rhea Huria

Photograph by Ayanna Handa for The Fraser Post

Edited by Simran Ahluwalia  

Teaching Cursive - The Continued Debate

OPINION

Works Cited

​

Lifestyle. “7 Key Reasons Why Cursive Writing Should Be Taught in School.” Lifestyle, 18 July 2019, blog.sfgate.com/lifestyle/2019/07/18/7-key-reasons-why-cursive-writing-should-be-taught-in-school/.

​

Long, Cindy. “The Great Cursive Writing Debate.” Www.nea.org, 2 Apr. 2022, www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/great-cursive-writing-debate#. Accessed 30 Nov. 2023.

​

Stegner, Ben. “The 4 Worst Arguments for Teaching Cursive in Schools.” MUO, 30 Dec. 2019, www.makeuseof.com/tag/4-worst-arguments-teaching-cursive-schools/.

bottom of page