The American Museum of Natural History (AMNH), located in New York, plans to remove all human remains from their exhibits. The museum, which holds around 12,000 human carcasses, has received backlash on account of the methods of collection by which they have acquired the skeletal remains of Indigenous and enslaved Black people.
Sean M. Decatur, the first African-American president of the AMNH, relayed that the collection of human remains was only possible through major imbalances of power, mainly regarding a lack of consent used to acquire these artifacts. Researchers in the 19th and 20th centuries used these collections to add research onto deeply flawed scientific inquiries searching for physical proof of white supremacy.
The ethics behind the collection of human remains was a major factor leading to their removal from being displayed in the museum. There are many cases where researchers have excavated sacred burial sites to acquire skeletons from private collections without the approval or permission of the living relatives of those bodies. Due to this problematic method of collection, there is a lack of information about the lives of individuals whose carcasses are now on display in the AMNH. Without the museum giving proper care or respect for the previous life of the carcass, it is as though they are simply objects on display.
The AMNH’s holdings contain the remains of 400 New Yorkers whose bodies were given to medical schools in the late 1940s. This group of cadavers is referred to as the “medical collection”. These deceased human bodies are donated to medical schools for students to perform dissection and conduct research on. Rather than being buried after their use, as is typical procedure, the bodies were given to AMNH.
In the 1940s, the state of New York had a law which declared that cadavers used as medical training for anatomy were not permitted to be transferred to any museum. “There is no expressly legal way for human remains to end up in a museum,” said Tanya Marsh, a professor at Wake Forest University. In response, the spokesman of the AMNH, Anne Canty, states that all remains have come into the museum’s possession by lawful means.
A prominent issue for the museum is that their collection of more recent bones, for example the bones from the “medical collection”, could very well have close, living relatives. Ashely Hammond, the chairwoman of the anthropology department, states that the museum would like to be in communication with the descendants' families themselves. However, they have been unable to start the process due to a limited supply of archive documents.
As the AMNH president, Decatur believes that it is not necessary to have remains to convey the narrative of any exhibitions.
In a letter from Decatur to the museum staff, he writes, “These are ancestors and are in some cases victims of violent tragedies or representatives of groups who were abused and exploited, and the act of public exhibition extends that exploitation.”
References
Blair, Elizabeth. “Natural History Museum Vows Better Stewardship of Human Bones.” NPR, NPR, 17 Oct. 2023, www.npr.org/2023/10/17/1206519798/natural-history-museum-vows-better-stewardship-of-human-bones.
“Board of Trustees.” American Museum of Natural History, www.amnh.org/about/board-of-trustees. Accessed 26 Oct. 2023.
Gamble, Justin. “New York’s American Museum of Natural History to Remove Human Remains from Exhibits, Including Some from Indigenous and Enslaved Black People.” CNN, Cable News Network, 19 Oct. 2023, www.cnn.com/2023/10/19/us/museum-of-natural-history-removing-human-remains/index.html.
Small, Zachary. “Facing Scrutiny, a Museum That Holds 12,000 Human Remains Changes Course.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 15 Oct. 2023, www.nytimes.com/2023/10/15/arts/american-museum-natural-history-human-remains.html.
Staff, News. “Ny Natural History Museum Changing How It Looks after Thousands of Human Remains in Collection.” CityNews Toronto, 26 Oct. 2023, toronto.citynews.ca/2023/10/26/ny-natural-history-museum-changing-how-it-looks-after-thousands-of-human-remains-in-collection/.

Written by Kirpa Chandi
Photography by Ananya Sithique Hasan for The Fraser Post
Edited by Tarek Chanouha
_edited.jpg)